In this Workholding Guide:
- The "Movement" Nightmare: Why holding matters
- Method 1: Mechanical Clamps (T-Tracks)
- Method 2: Vacuum Tables (Plenum & Gasketing)
- Cost Analysis: $50 vs $2,000
- The Verdict: Which one should you build?
There is a sound every CNC operator dreads. The machine is humming along perfectly, and then—CRUNCH. The part shifts, the bit grabs the material, and your project (and possibly your cutter) is destroyed.
Workholding is the most unglamorous but critical part of CNC routing. The debate usually comes down to two camps: The traditionalists using Clamps & T-Tracks, and the production shops using Vacuum Tables.
In this guide, we break down the costs, pros, and cons to decide which system belongs in your workshop.
Method 1: Mechanical Clamping (T-Tracks)
This is the standard for 90% of hobbyist machines (Shapeoko, X-Carve, Onefinity). You have aluminum rails embedded in your wasteboard, and you use clamps to physically pin the material down.
The Pros
- Holding Power: Mechanical force is unbeatable. You can take heavy aggression cuts in aluminum or hardwoods without slip.
- Low Cost: A set of clamps costs $40. T-Tracks cost $50.
- Versatility: Works on odd-shaped parts (like 3D carving a guitar body).
The Cons
- The "Collision" Risk: If you program your toolpath wrong, the bit will hit the steel clamp. This ruins the bit instantly.
- Bowing: If you clamp a thin sheet of plywood only at the edges, the middle can bow up, ruining your depth accuracy.
- Tabs: You must use "tabs" to keep parts from flying loose, which requires sanding later.
Method 2: Vacuum Tables
This is the "Dream" upgrade. A vacuum table pulls air through a porous wasteboard (usually MDF) or uses rubber gaskets to suck the part down flat.
The Pros
- Speed: Throw a sheet on, flip a switch, and cut. No tightening bolts.
- Flatness: It sucks warped plywood perfectly flat against the bed.
- Full Access: There are no clamps in the way. You can cut the entire surface of the material without fear of collision.
The Cons
- Cost: It is expensive. You need pumps, PVC plumbing, and valves.
- Power & Noise: A good vacuum system (like a Black Box or Regen Blower) pulls 10-20 Amps and sounds like a jet engine.
- Leakage: If you cut small parts, you lose vacuum pressure. It requires strategy (onion skinning).
The Financial Reality Check
Let's look at the real setup costs for a standard 4x4 CNC machine.
| System |
Required Gear |
Approximate Cost |
| T-Tracks |
MDF Board, Aluminum Tracks, Clamp Set |
$150 - $200 |
| DIY Vacuum (Shop Vac) |
MDF Plenum, Shop Vac (Will burn out eventually) |
$200 + Vacuum cost |
| Pro Vacuum (Blower) |
Regenerative Blower, PVC Piping, Relief Valves |
$800 - $2,500 |
The Secret Third Option: Tape & Glue
Before you spend $1,000 on a vacuum, try the "Maker's Favorite" trick.
- Put a strip of Blue Painters Tape on your machine bed.
- Put a strip of tape on the back of your workpiece.
- Apply CA Glue (Super Glue) between the tape strips and press down.
This acts like a vacuum table (holds the whole bottom surface, no clamps in the way) but costs $0.50 per project. It is perfect for aluminum and small parts.
The Verdict: The Winner
So, who wins?
For Sheet Goods (Cabinetry): Vacuum Wins
If you are cutting full 4x8 sheets of plywood for cabinets, a vacuum table is mandatory. The time saved in setup and the ability to flatten warped wood pays for the system in a month.
For Makers & Hobbyists: Clamps + Tape Wins
For the average "Great Meets" member making signs, guitars, or aluminum plates, a vacuum table is overkill. The noise and power consumption aren't worth it. Stick to a high-quality T-Track system and use the Tape & Glue method for small, tricky parts.
Show us your Bed!
Did you build a custom T-Track grid or design a clever vacuum plenum? Upload your Fusion 360 files or photos to the CNC & Fabrication forum to help others build their wasteboards.
Share Your Setup ?